home

about us

mission

contact us

The Prospect is published by The Indonesian Institute. Our messages are study, democracy and unity.
 

 

MAIN ISSUES
 

Democracy

 

Economy

 

Labor/Unemployment

 

Education

 

Development

 

Global Issues

 

Research

 

Contact Us:

Elwin Tobing

A Self-destructive Play or a Winning One

Fire and Ice

Promoting Dialog with a New Paradigm

Searching for Good Politicians (2)

Searching for Good Politicians (1)

Belajar Memahami Perbedaan

Internet and Knowledge Advancement

Information is not power

 


The choice between the four alphabetical words
vs

the majority’s blunder

 

Elwin Tobing

“The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." Edmund Burke

A series of short pieces on how to promote constructive dialog and understanding as well to promote a better Indonesia. See First things First (1), (2) and (3)

11/28/02

I often thank that I wasn’t born during the War World II. At that time Indonesia was occupied by Japan and from the history books as well as from the stories told by my parents, people’s lives during the occupation was a complete suffering. Thanks to the progress that had been made by both leaders and people of the countries, Japan and Indonesia have enjoyed a mutual economic relationship since the 1970s. Despite significant protests in the early 1970s of the influence of Japan on Indonesian economy which culminated in the Malari incidence in 1974, Indonesian people tried not to be held hostage by the past and now are striving to move from victim to victory.  Good luck.

On the other situation, Japan also was not held captive by their defeat and devastation during the war. Rather the country had become a number two or three as the strongest nation in the world economically.  Thanks to its people’s hard working and innovative attitude which seems suggest that hate and the commitment to destroy others are now becoming alien words for them.

As I watched a TV program at Discovery channel last night, portraying the suffering and the release of the American prisoners of war (POW) in Vietnam in the early 1970s, I was reminded once again that suffering and hate are essentially not sisters or brothers. They don’t belong to the same family. An ex POW who suffered for more than five years and, just like many other POWs, was brutally tortured told the interviewer what he felt about the people who tortured him. He said that our lives in this world is too short and too precious to be channeled for hate because, as he said, the consequences which are brought by hate are far more damaging to the hater than to the individual(s) or entity that he hates. His name is John McCain, a US presidential candidate in the 2000 election.

A few days before the first year of the September 11 memorial, a father who lost his daughter on the one of the planes hijacked from Boston and slammed into one of the twin towers told the interviewer from MSNBC cable news how he was copying with his loss. Instead of wasting his time by hating other people, he said he organized a small group of people to provide humanitarian assistance to the Afghan people. In addition, his small group went to Afghanistan and lived there for days sharing the misery of the Afghan people who were also suffered from the US bombings.

Sixty years ago, a physically weak and yet powerful mind gentleman, Gandhi urged his people in India not to respond their suffering from the British colonialization with hate rather he advocated them to fight peacefully, work hard and cooperate with one another. Undoubtedly, Gandhi emerged as the few who used the concepts of truth and love as weapons against suffering and injustice which have inspired many other freedom fighters in many other countries such as Martin Luther King, Jr. who used the concepts in his fight against racism in the US in 1960s.

In his fight for liberty and justice, Gandhi managed to show the British their sins. When Gandhi and his followers marched with him to the sea in order to protest the salt tax, the British beat them down, but they continued to walk peacefully. This stung the British conscience and through this the British realized their evils and the cruelty that lay in their oppression.

As an individual who was born in the late 1960s, I am well informed enough to know the horror of the Cold War, the brutality of the wars in Afghanistan and in the Middle East (Iran vs Iraq) in 1980s and many other horror stories from around the world. Those were inspired and energized by hate. And today, there is an unprecedented phenomenon where hate is even trying to rule the world. That makes me really unhappy of the current development.

The world has long been crazy but today is even crazier. It seems now our small planet is held hostage by the wrong four alphabetical words.

Instead of offering help, many people deny others.  Instead of being nice, many people slay others. Instead of providing care, many people envy others.

Instead of giving gift, many people raid others.  Instead of making themselves to be liked, many people fear others.  Instead of saying okay, many people veto others.

And instead of showing love, many people hate others.

There is no need to repeat here the bloody stories occurred around the globe from New York, Bali, Moscow, Nigeria, Middle East and other regions.  All were driven by a mixture of hate and misunderstanding about life. 

As much as love is, hate is also powerful, but it is powerful to bring people into a complete destruction.

Hate and love reside in people’s mind and heart. People are born with them and always with them in their daily lives.  But people do have a choice: a self-destruction or a victory.  Environment, teaching and education are all factors  that affect which direction that one will follow either to walk in the world of love or to march in the valley of hate.  Gandhi, the story of McCain and the father who lost his daughter in the September 11 have shown that people really do have a choice. Also, they show that the treatment of others often do not matter for their choice. It is all about conscience and the values they hold. There is no excuse.

The world now desperately needs people who can emulate the story of the father above.  The world also badly needs leaders and influential individuals like Gandhi, Martin Luther King Jr. and Mother Theresa. Each country must have at least one of those calibers these days in order to make the world a safer and a better place to live. But average people can do much more effective and efficient. How?

While there are individuals who commit evil acts, the number of good people is actually greater.  But when the good people are passive and act as if there are good reasons for evil acts, the world will be doomed very soon. 

Once Edmund Burke said, “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing."  Indeed, the good people of the world must take active role by showing the evil doers that their acts are totally wrong and by educating others not to worship hate and abandon love. Convincing others that we are good is not going to work unless we fight against evil doers and bring them to a realization that their choice is wrong. I call this a majority’s blunder.

 Your comment

Back to top

© 2002 The Prospect and The Indonesian Institute, All Rights Reserved. Do not reprint without express written permission