home

about us

mission

contact us

The Prospect is published by The Indonesian Institute. Our messages are study, democracy and unity.
 

 

MAIN ISSUES
 

Democracy

 

Economy

 

Labor/Unemployment

 

Education

 

Development

 

Global Issues

 

Research

 

Contact Us:

Elwin Tobing

Searching for Good Politicians (2)

Searching for Good Politicians (1)

Belajar Memahami Perbedaan

Internet and Knowledge Advancement

Information is not power

 


First Things First (2)

Promoting dialog and understanding with a new paradigm

Elwin Tobing

A better world shall emerge based on faith and understanding. Douglas MacArthur

A series of short pieces on how to promote constructive dialog and understanding as well to promote a better Indonesia. See First things First (1)
 

11/15/02

A few days ago I attended a break fasting service of Turkish Muslim community in Iowa City, the US. I came together with a good Ukranian friend of mine, Andrei Sirtchenko with his wife and baby girl.  Besides Turkish people, the service was packed with friends from Russia., China, Thailand, India, the United States and other parts of the world. All were happy and enjoyed each other conversation. Laugh, food and of course the famous traditional Turkish dessert, Baklava, were the main menu. No hatred and no prejudice. Welcome to a wonderful world!

Just as the fasting itself, breaking the fasting is an important ritual tradition for Muslim friends since it symbolizes a triumph over greedy and earthly desires. It is also a wonderful moment for expressing thankfulness to the Creator of the universe.  But not all of us who were there were Moslems. There were Buddhists, Hindus, Christians and Atheists. It was a small representation of the world. But we were there to celebrate life and thank the Highest One.  After all, we are human beings and have the same Creator.  So, if we can get together to thank the Creator, wouldn’t the Creator of the universe smile at us?

The first fundamental tenet of life

We perhaps often hear, ”Love the creation, because of the Creator.” All human beings - regardless their race, religion and nationality – are falling short before their Creator.  And in order to live up to the “expectation” of their Creator, human beings must love the Creator and the creation. To love creation but ignore the Creator is basically meaningless as it does not recognize the authority of the Creator. On the other hand, to love the Creator but destroy the creation is to deny the works of the Creator and accordingly deny the Creator Himself. This is the first fundamental tenet of life that many people forget: We cannot simultaneously praise and deny the Creator of the universe.

A tradition of attending a break fasting service is not something new for me as I used to live in one house or apartment with Muslim friends from Iran, Pakistan and Palestine. Amir, a wonderful Iranian guy, was my roommate a few years ago in Boston. Together with his sister and other Iranian friends we often discussed about many things in life.  Then I had Pakistani and Palestinian roommates and the cycles began again: dialog and understanding. The Pakistani, Akhtar, often mentioned that corruption and the lack of modern education are the main problem in his country. The Palestinian friend, more or less, told me the similar story: Corruption, incapable leaders and occupation. And my story was nothing but corruption and the fragile fundament of Indonesia’s unity. All of them are good Muslims but they take their belief as something personal. I am a Christian and treat my belief as something personal as well. No one has any intention to impose his or her belief on somebody else.

However, my close encounter with good friends from Turkey has given me a new horizon. While majority of its population are Muslims, Turkey remains a secular country. For more than two years, Necati Tecatli and Halil Kurt are especially two Turkish friends with whom I often discussed about humanity, power, religious and economic issues. Just like Amir and Akhtar, the Turkish friends also treat their belief as something personal. But Necati and Halil go even nobler. To them, religion is a fundament to enhance understanding about life and humanity, to foster kindness and love and to promote justice and equality.

And these are the values and principles that my belief teaches me, as well. But although there are similarities, I will not be naïve to admit that both our beliefs are perfectly the same.  In reality, our beliefs are different. But does the difference lead us into confrontation, hatred and prejudice? No, in fact it is just the opposite! Why?

Here is the secret. While we often have dialogs and discussion about many things, we never try to search the truth from our own side and impose it on others. Once it happens, it’s guaranteed that in less than a second evil and hatred will dominate our dialogs. Instead, we build our dialogs and discussion on a self-consensus principle that it is the concern for humanity, concern for love for the creation and our Creator that unite us. Those are the unifying factors that have energized and given the right spirit to our dialogs on many things in life. There is no demand to “please understand me and I will respect you” attitude.

That is the old paradigm of dialog in which to understand about other is the first step toward harmony and peace. According to this paradigm dialog is aimed at achieving understanding about others. But when the prerequisite to a dialog is an understanding about others, what is then the essence of dialog? The following comment from a reader in response to my article  “End corruption, political abuse, terror”  (the Jakarta Post October 19, 2002) nicely put the basis for my argument

"Communication and learning about others deeply from their own perspective are the first, then maybe we'll understand each other better and unite; and peace will come easier."

This is the old paradigm. The new one is: Understand first about humanity and be responsible for it. That's why we have:

The second fundamental tenet of life

The common problem in the world today is many people are trying to understand others very deeply from others’ perspective while ignoring their own selves. The East demand that the West should understand about them first, and vice versa.  Understanding about others will not guarantee a better world.  We don’t really need to learn about others deeply from their own perspective to have peace with others. Knowing that others are human beings, just like ourselves, is more than enough to promote peace with them. Is it the golden rule - Do unto your neighbors what they want them to do for you, not enough? The problem today is we demand other people first to understand us, but we are not trying to understand humanity.

It is the understanding about and the responsibility on humanity that have to be the basis for dialog across different religion, race and nationality. And talking about humanity, one cannot get away from the conversation of basic needs and human rights. The satisfactions of basic needs such as the need for food, protection, sanitation and etc. for all are the utmost responsibility of all people across religion, race and nationality. The fulfillments of human rights such as the right to speech, the right to live, the right to worship whatever God that one wants to worship and etc. are all the highest responsibility of all people across religion, race and nationality. But the biggest BUT of all is, in trying to fix and work on those two issues - the basic needs satisfaction and the human right fulfillment - people must not bring themselves back into square one that is destroying humanity for humanity clause. The end must never justify the means.  This is the second fundamental tenet of life that many people forget: We cannot simultaneously promote humanity while at the same time destroy it.

After about two hours, the break fasting service was over. As soon as I stepped out the room, the world was no longer perfect. I was back to the real world where prejudice, hatred and superiority are daily bread for millions of people around the world.  Welcome to a crazy world! But, with a new paradigm, we could turn the crazy world into a wonderful one.

Next: promoting dialog and understanding in Indonesia

First things First (1)

 Your comment

Back to top

© 2002 The Prospect and The Indonesian Institute, All Rights Reserved. Do not reprint without express written permission