home

about us

mission

contact us

The Prospect is published by The Indonesian Institute. Our messages are study, democracy and unity.
 

 

MAIN ISSUES
 

Democracy

 

Economy

 

Labor/Unemployment

 

Education

 

Development

 

Global Issues

 

Research

 

Contact Us:

Elwin Tobing

Daily Archives

Belajar Memahami Perbedaan

Internet and Knowledge Advancement

Information is not power

 


Terrorism and Our Future

Elwin Tobing

The ultimate security is your understanding of reality. H. Stanley Judd
True individual freedom cannot exist without economic security and independence. People who are hungry and out of a job are the stuff of which dictatorships are made. Franklin D. Roosevelt
Click here to read the published version in The Jakarta Post, 10/19/02
10/16/2002:

The aftermath of the terror in Bali is clear. There will be a sense of insecurity across the archipelago, a poorer image of the nation around the globe and a potential disaster of our economy.

For long, we have denied the presence of threats to our national security and ignored the very basic rule in life: if you don’t take care of yourselves someone will do it for you meaning that someone will destroy you. Now we find ourselves are extremely overwhelmed with a huge task to handle this terror and more likely we are not able to do that without international supports.

Also for long, corruption and destructive politics have ruined the future of the country, and now terrorism is holding our nation as hostage. Sadly, corruption, destructive politics and terrorism are three great recipes for a quick disaster of a nation. So, as a nation our choice is clear: whether we continue to exist or accept the ultimate reality that Indonesia will soon be remembered as history. Unless the nation fights back against the three poisonous recipes swiftly and resolutely, we will end up with the second choice. The bombings in Bali show us that the order of the tasks to be in the first choice is as follow: security, constructive politics and economy.

To start the job, the foremost step we must do is to examine ourselves and ask question, do we really have problems with ourselves? An honest answer to this will shut down a denial mentality. This mentality is the biggest problem with Indonesia.

The next step is to put away a blaming game from the table. The actors behind of the terror have to be found and prosecuted, but let the authority do the job. This is the time to come together, sit down and talk about the future of this nation.  After the September 11 attack in US, the American people were rallied behind their leaders and they were united. Although the bombings in Bali were mainly directed toward foreigners, but the attack was on the Indonesian soil and it was about lives.  Rallying together behind the government to capture and punish the terrorists and condemning terrorism will show that we value lives and reject terror. As a nation, we now need to ask critical questions: will we surrender our future to a group of people - whoever they are - who are trying to destroy this nation and secondly, what must we do to restore security across the nation

The need for strong law enforcement is a must.  But just like blood never wins a sympathy and sword never wins a heart, the authority needs to realize that machine guns alone will never be able to fully restore security in the country. It requires a new approach which combines muscles, productive ideas and humanity. The authority must walk in a fine line between protecting the integrity of the nation and at the same time preserving the human rights of our people. But one thing is certain, without strong muscles and punishment any effort to restore security is a joke.  Equivalently, without an active participation of public community, any effort to restore security will be ineffective.

While politicians have indirectly contributed to the insecurity in the country, public community has long been too passive in promoting public security.  The passive stance of public community often sent signals to terrorists that it is all right to hurt and kill innocent people.  Now, enough is enough. The despicable terror in Bali and the blood of thousands of innocent people in Moluccan, Poso and other parts of the country are enough. It is time for public community to participate actively in building and promoting national and local security. To start with, President Megawati has to address the nation of the urgency of building national and local security to the future of the nation. And Megawati has to appeal to her fellow Indonesians to be vigilant while keeping the high tolerance among people from different religion, ethnic groups and races.  She has to resolutely state that any activities and organizations or interest groups that promote hate and violence will be banned and punished.  The tolerance for violence and hate is zero, regardless its cause.  Words are then followed by determined actions.

A strong law enforcement and an active participation of public community do not guarantee a stable national security. It also requires a new paradigm in our national politics. As Bill Guerin in Asia Times puts this nicely, “This political manipulation using Islamic symbols is extremely dangerous and poses the greatest danger ever to Indonesia's stability since the downfall of Suharto. The crisis of leadership suffered by Indonesia that allows Islamic fundamentalism and terrorism to be confused with all Islamic movements, political and social, non-violent and violent, is driving a wedge between the West and the Indonesian Muslims. If the West and the Islamic world cannot meet in the middle, then the future holds only the frightening prospect of more hatred and radicalism...”

Politicians in Indonesia have long assumed that Indonesian people are unintelligent and easy to be manipulated. They make their political maneuvers based on that assumption such as the bizarre political tactic by the Vice President, Hamzah Haz – embracing a less popular group while abandoning his party grass root - and the shameful maneuver by the House of Representatives (DPR) Speaker and chairman of the Golkar party, Akbar Tanjung – resisting the demand to resign despite his conviction as felony. Sadly, President Megawati and her political advisors seem to employ this wrong assumption. They forget the basic fact that if the assumption were right, her party, Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle would never win the 1999 election.  Party leaders and elites must understand that people are now hungry, jobless and desperate for a good education and safety. So, any attempt to win votes in the 2004 election by selling religious and other exclusive symbols is no longer appealing for people.  People have already seen the good quality of lives in neighboring countries such as Singapore, Malaysia and Australia.  They have seen that countries which reduce the choice of their people into a binary choice - black and white - are all economically and politically backward.

Most parties and interest group leaders are now more interested in the upcoming 2004 election rather than in the future of the country.  For them, my advice is this: “if your party is a party of exclusion and able to provide prosperity and security to all Indonesian people, you are the winner. But if your party is a party of inclusion and cannot offer prosperity and security to all Indonesians, you are a loser.”

Right now people need progress, not regress. People need peace with one another, not hatred. And people already know which way to realize progress and which way to promote peace. Never try to fool them because it is not going to work.

Published version in The jakarta Post

 Your comment

Back to top

© 2002 The Prospect and The Indonesian Institute, All Rights Reserved.