home

about us

mission

contact us

The Prospect is published by The Indonesian Institute. Our messages are study, democracy and unity.
 

 

MAIN ISSUES
 

Democracy

 

Economy

 

Labor/Unemployment

 

Education

 

Development

 

Global Issues

 

Research

 

Contact Us:

Elwin Tobing

Masa Depan Indonesia: Antara Dana dan Partai
Who Are Our Neighbors?
Seputar Kepemimpinan Nasional
Asal Mula Krisis? Perbankan Nasional 5 Tahun Pakto 88
Should We Believe in the World Bank and the IMF?
Do Media Serve Democracy?
The New New World Order

April 2002:

Who Are Our Neighbors? 

A foundation for unity and prosperity

Elwin Tobing

If you want to be free, there is but one way; it is to guarantee and equally full measure of liberty to all your neighbors. There is no other. Carl Schurz.

There are many things in life that we can select. For example, as long as we have enough resources we can select what we eat for lunch or dinner. We can also select what clothes to wear, books to read or car to drive. Our resources such as money and power will enable us to do that.

 

But there are things in life where we don't have much freedom to select no matter how much resources we have. The obvious example is our parents. One may wish to have wealthy parents, but as long as he was born into and raised by another family, his wish is nothing but empty hope. Regardless the bulk resources one has, he can never change such reality. The best he can do is to accept the reality and work to serve the best interest of himself, his parents and the people around him.

 

There is another thing that we don't have much freedom in selecting what we want: our neighbors. One may be able to choose people to live with or associated with. But all of them are still people, his neighbors. What neighbors mean are all people, not certain people who live in our neighborhood. There is a proverb that goes, “Do unto your neighbors what they want them to do for you.” This means that do unto all people, not only to the people around us such as closed friends or family members.

 

When it comes to this matter, therefore, it becomes a binary choice, either one must live with people or not at all. One may have abundant resources, but one cannot choose to live with aliens or animals without affecting his being. One may decide to live in a jungle or an isolated island, away from human beings but as we have seen from the movie Cast Away, what one gets will be a total alienation.

 

The complexity of life has often limited our horizon in understanding who our neighbors are and what the best we can do for them are. Even worse, some people not only fail to understand the real meaning of neighbors but also develop an attitude that tends to choose who will be their neighbors. In case they cannot choose their neighbors, they will define who will be their neighbors and if necessary change other people's beings to be suitable to their definition.

 

The end of humanity is if people start thinking uniformity as the golden rule and imposing the rule to others. By thinking uniformity as the golden rule, one automatically defines who will be his neighbors and who will be not. In other words, he will build strict boundaries in his life as to which people he can associated with and to which people he cannot. In such case, the person not only fails to understand the real meaning of neighbors but also falls short to comprehend his own being.

 

Such ways of thinking and life can also happen to a group of people. A group of people can build strict boundaries and apply them to their neighbors. Once they impose their rules to others strictly, the humanity is essentially vanished. Take for example a simple case of myself who is studying economics. Once I build a boundary in which only people who are studying economics to be my neighbors and impose my rules to them and to the people who are not studying economics, what my life would be? Nothing is but misery. There are many things outside of economics which are interesting and resorting myself to only one part of the world would be a loss.

 

The problem with a very diverse nation such as Indonesia is how to find people with great sense of humanity and unity. People tend to ignore or less appreciate the beauty of life when they live in a diverse society. Heterogeneity is often viewed as something that needs to be transformed into homogeneity. This view fails to understand the fundamental character and need of human beings: diversity and liberty. No two people, regardless their backgrounds, have exactly the same character. Even if two people have the same DNA structure, through cloning for example, they will still have different character since they will have different perception about life. This is a fundamental reality of life.

 

In the same spirit, no one is willing to be a slave who does not have liberty. This is another fundamental reality of life that every one should know. Therefore, when someone imposes his rules on another person, essentially the first person is trying to take away two of the most fundamental realities from the latter: Liberty and diversity.

 

We, of course, are living in a real world where no one will ever be able to please everybody. However, rules and boundaries are something that people can make in order to promote liberty and enhance peace among people from all backgrounds.

 

No rule that destroys liberty and diversity can be called as noble rule. When it destroys liberty and diversity, it essentially annihilates humanity, and when it annihilates humanity, it only brings misery and suffering. No prosperity in such circumstances exists at all.

 

The future of Indonesia will be completely determined by how its people view diversity and liberty as two fundamental realities that need to be maintained and enhanced. Any intention and movement that tend to destroy the two realities will result in a chaos and misery, not only to the ones who are out of the boundaries, but also to the whole people. The energy required to make a universal rule to promote liberty and unity in diversity is less compared to the energy we will spend on imposing a specific rule for all. It's up to us, which way that we want to develop.

 

We can select our clothes for not to suffer from bad weather, but we cannot select our neighbors without bringing suffering to all.

 

Your comment

Back to top

© 2002 The Prospect and The Indonesian Institute, All Rights Reserved.